In 2025, Americans' trust in traditional news media has hit its lowest point ever at 26%. Social media algorithms decide what we see. Editorial desks filter what gets published. And consumers have had enough.
The result of collapsing media trust? A massive shift toward direct relationships. For the first time, brands are expected to spend more on influencer marketing than on digital ads —a $32.55 billion industry. User-generated content on Reddit trains Google's AI. First-person video dominates every platform. 69% of consumers trust influencers' recommendations over information straight from a brand.
People haven't stopped trusting content—they've stopped trusting gatekeepers.
Here's what makes email newsletters fascinating: while other "traditional" channels hemorrhage trust, email has somehow maintained its position. Consider these statistics:
Why? Because email newsletters have always operated on the principles that are now revolutionizing media: direct relationships, demonstrated value, and earned trust. No algorithm. No editorial board. No gatekeeper. Just a direct line from creator to subscriber—the same dynamic now driving the creator economy.
Newsletters have been doing what podcasters and influencers do now, but they've been doing it for decades. The playbook is identical:
Just as podcasters get people to subscribe, then listen regularly, then buy merch and attend live shows, newsletter creators have long understood that trust compounds. This is why mainstream media figures have flocked to platforms like Substack—they recognize that people trust a direct relationship over a corporate one.
More than 90% of Americans subscribe to at least one email newsletter. When readers subscribe, they're not subscribing to a platform or publication—they're subscribing to you. They've explored your brand, evaluated your ideas, and made a conscious choice to let you into their inbox.
Now that we understand why newsletters remain relevant—they've always been about direct relationships—how do you make them work in today's multi-channel environment?
The answer isn't to treat newsletters as a standalone tactic. 71% of B2B marketers use email newsletters as part of their content marketing strategy, alongside video, social, and influencer campaigns. The most successful brands understand that trust built through email amplifies every other marketing effort.
Here's the strategic framework:
While you're creating TikToks, partnering with influencers, and optimizing for SEO, your newsletter quietly builds the deepest relationships. Email is considered the most personal method of brand communication by 74% of Baby Boomers, 72% of Gen X, and 64% of Millennials. Use it to demonstrate consistent value.
Your newsletter should feel like it comes from a person, not a brand. Using a personal name instead of a company name can increase open rates by 35%. This isn't a trick—it's acknowledging that people want relationships with people, not logos.
People treat their time like currency. They don't want to waste it on content that doesn't align with their values—they see this as a threat to their personal and professional capital. Be direct, be valuable, eliminate fluff. Subject lines with 20 or fewer characters achieve 37.6% open rates versus 28.68% for 80+ characters.
Trust doesn't directly generate sales. Instead, it creates a self-reinforcing cycle that transforms how people perceive your entire brand. Here's how it works:
61% of consumers want to receive promotional marketing emails at least once per week. They're not just tolerating marketing—they're requesting it. This permission transforms you from an interruption into an anticipated guest.
The majority of marketers send 1-2 newsletters per week, achieving open rates of 43% and click-through rates of 5.7%. But frequency matters less than reliability. Show up when you promise, and readers incorporate you into their routines.
The 90/10 rule remains sacred: dedicate 90% of content to value, 10% to promotion. High-quality, relevant content builds trust—this is the cornerstone of newsletter success.
When you tell stories that emphasize your values, mission and authenticity, you activate the limbic system and foster trust. This neurological response means trust in your newsletter extends to everything your brand touches.
Your newsletter isn't separate from your brand—it's a weekly demonstration of what you stand for. This alignment is critical because 84% of consumers buy from brands that share their personal values, and 76% would rather buy from a brand they feel connected to than its competitor.
Three principles for value alignment:
If your brand promises simplicity, your newsletter should be scannable and clear. If you promise innovation, showcase cutting-edge thinking. The newsletter becomes proof of your brand promise in action.
People want assurance you're "about that life." Your newsletter values must align with what you demonstrate on social media, your website, and in your products. That connection must be consistent across every touchpoint.
In an attention economy, respecting time is respecting currency. Be direct, be visual, offer multiple value points, and eliminate fluff.
Curation alone no longer suffices. Anyone can aggregate links. What readers want is perspective, interpretation, and unique insight that helps them make sense of an overwhelming world.
The shift looks like this:
This evolution matters because increasing brand awareness is the top goal for 67% of B2B brands, and awareness comes from distinctive perspective, not information aggregation.
The data on what makes people open emails has evolved significantly:
45% of subscribers open emails based on who it's from, while only 33% open based on subject line. Yet 89% of campaigns still use company names rather than personal names.
65% of all email opens happen on mobile devices. 42.3% of users delete emails that aren't mobile-optimized.
Personalized subject lines can increase open rates by 26%. 74% of people hate being shown irrelevant content, making personalization essential to trust.
The types of value that move the needle have evolved. It's no longer enough to be useful—you must be meaningful:
Don't just provide information—provide it through the lens of your mission. If you're about democratizing access to tools, show readers how to achieve enterprise results with free resources. Your functional value serves your emotional value.
Offer newsletter subscribers exclusive content and access, but make it about belonging to something bigger. Patagonia's newsletters don't just offer gear discounts—they offer membership in the environmental movement.
61% of respondents find relatable personalities most appealing. Nothing's more relatable than respectfully challenging industry orthodoxy when it doesn't serve your community's interests.
Share experiments that demonstrate your values in action. Testing sustainable practices, trying inclusive hiring, experimenting with transparent pricing—these stories build trust through vulnerability.
The most effective newsletters never explicitly sell—they demonstrate shared values that make the sale inevitable:
Your newsletter should be a weekly demonstration of the values that drive your product. If your software is about simplifying complexity, your newsletter should make complex topics simple every week.
Start with what your community needs, not what you're selling. Address their challenges through your values lens. Your product becomes the natural extension of your values, not the focus.
Admitting product shortcomings builds trust, but frame it through your values: "We built this for small teams, so it won't have every enterprise feature—and that's by design."
Ready to build a newsletter that generates real trust and loyalty? Here's your action plan:
As we navigate an increasingly AI-saturated, algorithm-driven digital landscape, newsletters represent something precious: human-curated, trust-based communication that readers actually want to receive.
The opportunity is massive. Email marketing revenue is projected to reach $17.9 billion by 2027. 30% of marketers cite email as having the highest ROI of all digital channels. But success requires understanding that newsletters aren't a standalone tactic—they're part of an integrated strategy where trust built through email amplifies every other marketing effort.
The newsletters that will thrive aren't those with the biggest lists or the flashiest designs. They're the ones that understand the fundamental equation:
Trust = Consistency + Value + Authenticity + Time
You can't hack trust. You can't growth-hack loyalty. But you can engineer both through deliberate, thoughtful, consistent delivery of value that makes your readers' lives tangibly better.
Remember: in a world where 69% of consumers trust influencers over brands, your newsletter is your opportunity to become the trusted voice in your readers' inbox—not as a brand, but as a valued advisor who happens to have solutions worth considering.
Ready to see these principles in action? Subscribe to Funnel Vision for weekly insights on marketing automation for budget-conscious teams. Full disclosure: It's my newsletter, and it follows every principle outlined above.